Do you agree with Le Grand’s claim that choice gives power to voice?


PayPal Acceptance Mark


Order Details
1. Le Grand (2003) argues that most public policy design and implementation is based on assumptions about human behaviour
2003-2005 Senior Policy Adviser to Blair led to quasi markets in health and education: The Other Invisible Hand: Delivering Public Services through Choice and Competition (2007).
2. People who finance, operate and use the welfare state were:
Knights AND
Pawns
But are now
Knaves AND
Queens
Public services are organised by policymakers to reflect assumptions about motivations.
3. If governments consider public servants to be Knights – i.e. public need is above self interest, want to help people, not driven by salary
Then they are not concerned about how ‘goods’ delivered
Provide funds and let experts/professionals get on with the job
But… low quality, patronising & inequitable (1945-79)
4. Best incentive structure is to think of public sector workers as having knightly and knavish motivations
Part self-sacrifice, part self-interest e.g. pay GPs to carry out minor patient tests
Cheaper to set targets
Combination may deliver best results for users; and users can transform from Pawns to Queens.
5. Different public sector roles, different motivations: e.g. doctors versus care workers
Anti-target culture can still be a knightly motivation – freedom to do a good job for their users/clients
Is pre-Thatcher characterisation accurate?
Assumptions about Knaves and Pawns – assumes autonomy & personal responsibility for disadvantage rather than structural



PayPal Acceptance Mark

Do You Need A Similar Assignment?

Place an order with us. Our skilled and experienced writers will deliver a custom paper which is not plagiarized within the deadline which you will specify.

Note; 6 Hours urgent orders deliver also available.

If you need more clarifications contact our support staff via the live chat for immediate response.

 

Type of paper Academic level Subject area
Number of pages Paper urgency Cost per page:
 Total:

Tags: